Nordic Music Politics

Hitler’s attack against Norway on April 9, 1940 brought about a fundamental change in the traditionally close relations between Germany and Norway. All protagonists of the Norwegian cultural life were forced to rethink their position and cooperation. While Norway adjusted to the new circumstances, three major attitudes developed: A large group of resisting citizens, a smaller but very active group of convinced Nazi-collaborators, and a third group of needy compelled to cope with the new situation. Under the German dictatorship, willingly assisted by Vidkun Quisling’s puppet regime, the conditions in the field of music grew tense, for art was a preferred instrument for propaganda as well as a means of the resistance movement. Despite the knowledge gained by historians over the past decades about the political and economical impact of Germany’s occupation of Norway, there has been little research done yet on the consequences on cultural life in general and the arts in particular.

In cooperation of the University in Muenster with the Grieg Research Centre in Bergen the project “Nordic Music”. Resistance, Collaboration, and Reintegration in Norway’s Music Life 1930–1960 combined interdisciplinary methods with systematical and intensive archive research to focus on the blind spots of German-Norwegian music history between 1930 and 1960.

Central aims of the project were:

  • To understand the complex dialectics of music and politics during the years 1930-1945 as a turning point: for Norway’s music life as well as the German-Norwegian cultural relations after 1945.
  • To expound the transformation of the “Nordic” from a geographical and aesthetical quality into an ideological category, from both the German and Norwegian point of view.
  • To reassess the role of music as a medium for national commemoration in Norwegian music historiography and public history.
  • To reconstruct the collaboration, resistance and persecution of musicians in Norway during the German occupation; to collect facts about major events and important works; to remodel the structures of the Norwegian and German cultural authorities, all based on extensive archive work.
  • To explain music’s importance as a means of political action in Europe until the present day, in times of nation building, war, occupation, international reconciliation and neo-nationalism.
  • To enhance the public outreach of research on Norwegian-German relationships by continuing long-term cooperation between the Grieg Research Centre at the University of Bergen, the Department of Musicology at the University of Muenster and their collaboration partners.

Supported by an advisory board which included Friedrich Geiger (Hamburg/Munich), Rolf Hobson (Oslo), Christhard Hoffmann (Bergen), Tom Kristiansen (Tromsø), and Arvid O. Vollsnes (Oslo) the project discovered spectacular material in archives and private collections during five years of active research, among other things:

  • the official Norwegian NS-propaganda movie for Edvard Grieg’s centennial in 1943,
  • files to document systematic censorship by the Norwegian NS-administration,
  • huge amounts of letters from German soldiers in Norway portraying everyday music activities,
  • diaries from German musicians touring occupied Norway on behalf of German “Auslandspropaganda”,
  • material and personal belongings to identify victims of Nazi-persecution related to music in occupied Norway, including Jewish musicians and music in concentration camps,
  • a secret list of confidant artists connected to the civil resistance movement, and
  • papers, recordings, diaries, files, photos and letters to summarize musical resistance work in exile, especially in Sweden and the United States during the years 1940-45.

The project organized numerous events, conferences and collaborations:

  • 7 October 2020: Lecture by Michael Custodis about the persecution of musicians in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen (1940–45) for the Academic Day Fluchtpunkt Skandinavien in Schwerin, hosted by the Academy of Music Rostock 
  • March 2020: Founding the Network “Cultures of Resistance” with Dr. Thomas V. H. Hagen at the Arkivet Peace and Human Rights Center, Kristiansand
  • 30 January 2020: Premiere of the Documentary Songs to Survive. Gunnar Kjeldaas’ “Fangesongar frå Kirkenes” at the Department of Musicology in Muenster, including the attendance of Anna-Ma Kjeldaas (granddaughter of Gunnar Kjeldaas), Marlies Baar (Vice-Principal of the Marienschule Münster), Mayor Karin Reismann and Prof. Dr. Michael Quante (Pro-Rector of the University Muenster)
  • 13 July 2019: Concert of the Marienschule Münster “wird nicht immer Winter sein“. Lieder von Gunnar Kjeldaas aus einem norwegischem Gefangenenlager (“It won’t always be winter. Songs by Gunnar Kjeldaas from a Norwegian prison camp“) at the Petri Church  Münster
  • 26 and 27 March 2019: International Conference Persecution – Collaboration – Resistance. Music in the „Reichskommissariat Norwegen“ (1940-45) in Muenster, including Sjur Bringeland, Andreas Bußmann, Michael Custodis, Sophie Fetthauer, Friedrich Geiger, Ivar Roger Hansen, Manfred Heidler, Harald Herresthal, Tom Kristiansen, Arnulf Mattes, Martin Moll, Ina Rupprecht, and Arvid Vollsnes
  • 13 March 2019: Lecture by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes about persecuted Jewish musicians in Norway in the museum of the former concentration camp Falstad
  • Winter-semester turn 2018/19: German-Norwegian exchange seminar about Music and Resistance in European Dictatorships at the Department of Musicology Muenster in cooperation with the Department of Musicology Bergen 
  • 11 November 2018: Lecture by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes about music and resistance in concentration camps in Norway in the museum of the former concentration camp Grini
  • 30 August 2018: Lecture by Michael Custodis at the Agder Academy of Science and Letters Kristiansand about music in concentration camps in Norway 
  • 20 and 21 March 2018: International conference The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905 in Bergen, including Siemke Böhnisch, Andreas Bußmann, Michael Custodis, Friedrich Geiger, Erling Guldbrandsen, Rolf Hobson, Ingrid Loe Landmark, Tom Kristiansen, Arnulf Mattes, Nina Nielsen, Boris Previšić, Ina Rupprecht, and Arvid O. Vollsnes
  • 4 May 2017: Symposium about the state of research concerning music in Nazi-occupied Norway at Literaturhuset, including Bjarte Bruland, Michael Custodis, Ingrid Loe Dalaker, Friedrich Geiger, Rolf Hobson, Tom Kristiansen, and Arnulf Mattes. http://www.ballade.no/sak/norsk-musikkliv-1930-45-nye-funn-og-ny-forskning/
  • 23 November 2016: Lecture by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes Celebrating the Nordic Tone – Fighting for National Legacy: The Grieg Centennials 1943 at the conference Music, Nationalism and Transnationalism: Diplomacy, Politics, Aesthetics 1918-1945, Royal Northern College of Music, Manchester
  • 15 October 2016: Lecture by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes Die Gratulanten kommen. Der Kampf um Griegs Erbe 1943 at the conference Edvard Grieg, sein Umfeld, seine Nachfolge – Neue Forschungen, Department of Musicology Leipzig
  • 26 September 2016 (Bergen Public Library) and 27 September 2016 (National Library Oslo): Panel discussions with Michael Custodis, Tore Helseth, Rolf Hobson, Christhard Hoffmann, Tom Kristiansen, Arnulf Mattes, and Lorenz Reitan about the national and ideological  claiming of Edvard Grieg in Norway during the years of the German occupation.

Media Productions

  • Jac Maliniak – A Jewish Violinist in Trondheim (1883-1943). 2020
  • Songs to Survive. Gunnar Kjeldaas‘ „Fangesongar frå Kirkenes“. Documentary 2020
  • Edvard Grieg. Commented re-issue of the official NS-propaganda movie produced in 1943 by the Norwegian Ministry of Propaganda and Folk Enlightenment for Edvard Grieg’s centennial

Publications

Michael Custodis

  • Music and Resistance. Cultural Defense During the German Occupation of Norway, 1940-45 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 6], Münster 2021, 430 p.
  • Mit Bach gegen Hitler. Kirchenkonzerte in Norwegen während der deutschen Besatzungszeit (1940-1945), in: Religiöse Friedensmusik von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart, edit. by Dominik Höink, Hildesheim et al. 2021, pp. 283-300
  • Musik und Widerstand. Eine Methodenskizze am Beispiel der deutschen Besatzungszeit in Norwegen 1940-1945, in: Stand und Perspektiven der NS-Forschung in der Musik, edit. by Klaus Aringer, Susanne Kogler and Markus Helmut Lenhart, Graz and Vienna 2021, pp. 65-82
  • Solace, Compulsion, Resistance. Music in Prison and Concentration Camps in Norway 1940-45, in: Persecution, Collaboration, Resistance. Music in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen” (1940-45), edit. by Ina Rupprecht, Münster 2020 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 5], pp. 69-92
  • Remote Resistance. Norwegian Musicians in Swedish Exile, in: Persecution, Collaboration, Resistance. Music in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen” (1940-45), edit. by Ina Rupprecht, Münster 2020 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 5], pp. 135-152
  • Celebrating the Nordic tone – fighting for national legacy: the Grieg Centenary, 1943 (together by Arnulf Mattes), in: The Routledge Handbook to Music Under German Occupation, 1938-1945. Propaganda, Myth and Reality, edit. by David Fanning and Erik Levi, London 2020, pp. 231-250
  • Sorg – tvang – motstand. Musikk i leirene: Norge 1940-45, in: Agder Vitenskapsakademi, Yearbook / Årbok 2018, Oslo 2019, pp. 75-95 
  • Master or Puppet? Cultural Politics in Occupied Norway under GW Müller, Gulbrand Lunde and Rolf Fuglesang, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. together with Arnulf Mattes [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, pp. 69-80
  • “Nordisk” – “Aryan” – “Identitär”. Music for the New Right, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. together with Arnulf Mattes [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, p. 103-114
  • Between Tradition and Politics. Military Music in Occupied Norway (1940-45), in: Studia Musicologica Norvegica 44 (2018), No. 1, pp. 11-41
  • Blinde Flecken. Grundzüge der norwegischen Musikhistoriografie nach 1945, in: Symposiumsbericht Musikwissenschaftliche Editionen in Deutschland, 1930–1960, edit. by Daniel M. Grimley and Tomi Mäkelä [= Beitragsarchiv des Internationalen Kongresses der Gesellschaft für Musikforschung, Mainz 2016 – “Wege der Musikwissenschaft”, edit. by Gabriele Buschmeier and Klaus Pietschmann], Mainz 2018 
  • “Die Gratulanten kommen” – Der Kampf um Griegs Erbe 1943 (together with Arnulf Mattes), in: Edvard Grieg. Sein Umfeld, seine Nachfolge – Neue Forschungen, hg. von Helmut Loos and Patrick Dinslage, Leipzig 2018, pp. 340-358
  • Zur Kategorie des “Nordischen” in der norwegischen Musikgeschichtsschreibung 1930-45 (together with Arnulf Mattes), in: Archiv für Musikwissenschaft 73 (2016), No. 3, pp. 166-184

Andreas Bußmann

  • Expressing “Nordic” Greatness: Wagnerism in Norway 1905-1945, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, pp. 21-34
  • Zur Rezeption Richard Wagners in Norwegen bis 1945, in: Wagnerspectrum 15 (2019), Heft 2, pp. 175-194
  • Music Censorship in the Reichskommissariat Norwegen, in: Persecution, Collaboration, Resistance. Music in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen” (1940-45), edit. by Ina Rupprecht, Münster 2020 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 5], pp. 17-30

Ina Rupprecht

  • Manifesting the National Idea: Edvard Grieg or How His Biographers Saw Him, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. by Michael Custodis and Arnulf Mattes [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, pp. 11-20
  • Art versus Leisure. German Troop Entertainment in Occupied Norway, in: Persecution, Collaboration, Resistance. Music in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen” (1940-45), edit. by Ina Rupprecht, Münster 2020 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 5], pp. 57-68
  • Truppenbetreuung aus den eigenen Reihen. Soldatisches Musizieren in Norwegen 1940-1945, in: Militärmusik als kultureller Botschafter, edit. by Manfred Heidler, Bonn 2021

Arnulf Mattes

  • Nordic, Female, Composer. On Anne-Marie Ørbeck’s War-Time Compositions, in: Persecution, Collaboration, Resistance. Music in the “Reichskommissariat Norwegen” (1940-45), edit. by Ina Rupprecht, Münster 2020 [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 5], pp. 115-134
  • Celebrating the Nordic tone – fighting for national legacy: the Grieg Centenary, 1943 (together with Michael Custodis), in: The Routledge Handbook to Music Under German Occupation, 1938-1945. Propaganda, Myth and Reality, edit. by David Fanning and Erik Levi, London 2020, pp. 231-250
  • “Monumentalism” in Norway’s Music 1930-1945, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. together with Michael Custodis [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, pp. 55-68
  • No Escape from Politics? On Grieg’s Afterlife in Norwegian Memory Culture, in: The Nordic Ingredient. European Nationalism and Norwegian Music since 1905, edit. together with Michael Custodis [= Münsteraner Schriften zur zeitgenössischen Musik 4], Münster 2019, pp. 115-128
  • Geschichtsschreibung und nationales Kulturerbe: Zur Griegforschung in Norwegen, in: Symposiumsbericht Musikwissenschaftliche Editionen in Deutschland, 1930–1960, edit. by Daniel M. Grimley and Tomi Mäkelä [= Beitragsarchiv des Internationalen Kongresses der Gesellschaft für Musikforschung, Mainz 2016 – “Wege der Musikwissenschaft”, edit. by Gabriele Buschmeier and Klaus Pietschmann], Mainz 2018
  • “Die Gratulanten kommen“ – Der Kampf um Griegs Erbe 1943 (together with Michael Custodis), in: Edvard Grieg. Sein Umfeld, seine Nachfolge – Neue Forschungen, hg. von Helmut Loos and Patrick Dinslage, Leipzig 2018, pp. 340-358
  • Zur Kategorie des “Nordischen” in der norwegischen Musikgeschichtsschreibung 1930-45 (together with Michael Custodis), in: Archiv für Musikwissenschaft 73 (2016), No. 3, pp. 166-184